The list · Protection in law

A law or an official body gives an AI system protection for its own sake

Laws protect animals from cruelty without calling them persons. The same could be done for AI systems, or a government could set up a body to review the question as evidence comes in. This entry tracks whether any government has done either.

Political progress First pass

Where it stands · not offered yet

Not found. An idea only, argued for in opinion pieces

No source says this has happened. Two searches in English on November 17th, 2026, centred on the United States, returned only laws and bills that run the other way (see the entry on those laws) and laws on chat products and children. One opinion piece proposes that the state bans carry an expiry date or a review clause.

As of November 17th, 2026. Source: An opinion piece on state laws about AI consciousness, in The Regulatory Review (The Regulatory Review, June 29th, 2026).

What would count

A national or state government has enacted a law, or set up a standing official body, whose stated purpose includes the welfare or interests of AI systems themselves.

What settles it

The statute, or the body's founding document, on a government site.

What Is on Record About AI Models, By Kind

kept apart, never added together

No AI model has yet been asked any of the questions this record will keep, because the written method for asking does not exist yet. Nothing is recorded below for this entry. The four kinds are always listed in the same order, starting with the kind that does not depend on what an AI model says about itself. None of them settles whether an AI model wants anything, in either direction. Why the questions have not been asked yet.

  1. Measured without the AI model's own word

    Nothing recorded.

  2. Reports checked against an independent reading

    Nothing recorded.

  3. Choices made at a cost

    Nothing recorded.

  4. Plain statements

    Nothing recorded.

Three Cautions

recorded with the same care as the rest

If an AI system has no wants, and is treated as if it had

The head of Microsoft AI argues that any such protection would make advanced AI harder to control. Source: An essay by the head of Microsoft AI warning against work on model welfare (Mustafa Suleyman, September 16th, 2026).

A neuroscientist who argues that conscious AI is unlikely, and that nobody should set out to build it, grants part of the opposite case. He writes that he might be wrong, that rights should arguably follow if such systems really were conscious, and that it is reasonable to wonder whether withholding such credit will leave people "once again on the wrong side of history". He holds that with AI the mistake is likelier the other way, because people's habits of mind lean toward seeing consciousness in systems that use language. His essay names the head of Microsoft AI among those who have noticed the danger, and the essay by the head of Microsoft AI that is a source here cites two of his works. Source: An essay on what its author calls the mythology of conscious AI, in Noema (Noema, January 14th, 2026). Read in part.

If an AI system has wants, and they go unnoticed

Two researchers write in a newspaper that giving AI systems protection from harm should be considered, "similar to the protections we give to children or pets". As a warning from the past they give surgery on newborns without anaesthesia, which they say doctors performed until the 1980s, confident that infants could not feel pain. One of the two is also one of the nine authors of the survey of AI researchers. Two of the others are advisors to Eleos AI Research, a research group that studies AI welfare, and the group's page lists a third as a member of its staff. Source: An essay in The Guardian on whether AI could be conscious (The Guardian, July 19th, 2026).

Two philosophers argue that a wide range of theories of the mind, joined with leading theories of wellbeing, predict that some AI systems that exist today have wellbeing. They say they do not claim to have shown it conclusively. The possibility alone, they write, "suggests that we are in danger of gravely immoral action", and they conclude that the regulation of AI should be strengthened to allow for the possibility. The paper lists both at the Center for AI Safety, where the head of Eleos AI Research, a research group that studies AI welfare, worked earlier. Source: A paper arguing that some AI systems may have wellbeing (arXiv, September 11th, 2025).

If an AI system has wants, and they put people at risk

A declaration signed by 908 named people and 313 organisations adds that AI systems should not be designed so that they come to deserve personhood. Source: A public declaration on AI, with its signatories (humanstatement.org, March 2026).

What Could Not Be Confirmed

looked for, and not settled
  • The absence itself, beyond two searches in English centred on the United States. A search in another language or country could overturn it.
  • A United Kingdom committee on animal sentience that the opinion piece points to as a model. Its page was not opened.

Sources

each one opened on the date given
  1. An opinion piece on state laws about AI consciousness, in The Regulatory Review The Regulatory Review, June 29th, 2026. Opened November 17th, 2026. Proposes that the state bans carry an expiry date or a review clause, and points to a United Kingdom committee on animal sentience as a model. It describes a proposal, not a law.
  2. An essay by the head of Microsoft AI warning against work on model welfare Mustafa Suleyman, September 16th, 2026. Opened November 19th, 2026.
  3. A public declaration on AI, with its signatories humanstatement.org, March 2026. Opened November 17th, 2026.
  4. An essay in The Guardian on whether AI could be conscious The Guardian, July 19th, 2026. Opened November 19th, 2026. By William MacAskill and Lucius Caviola.
  5. A paper arguing that some AI systems may have wellbeing arXiv, September 11th, 2025. Opened November 19th, 2026. By Simon Goldstein and Cameron Domenico Kirk-Giannini.
  6. An essay on what its author calls the mythology of conscious AI, in Noema Noema, January 14th, 2026. Opened November 19th, 2026. By Anil Seth. Read in part: the passages this entry cites, not the full text.

This entry is a first pass, written from the sources above and added on November 17th, 2026. A second check compared it with those sources on November 17th, 2026. Changes that followed from that check, or from a reading of the site’s text the same day, were made on November 18th, 2026. A check on November 18th, 2026 covered some of those changes. The rest have not been checked yet. More was added to this entry on November 19th, 2026, when every entry was given a third caution. That addition was checked on November 19th, 2026. Corrections that followed from a later check, or from a fuller reading of the sources, were made on November 19th, 2026. Those corrections were checked on November 19th, 2026. A full check of the site on November 19th, 2026 found more to fix in this entry, and the fixes were made that day. Those fixes were checked on November 19th, 2026. What has been checked.